Najafi Q&A: Clinical Death
lit 8/29/2026 · 2 entries · 0 followers · 0 likes
⚖️ Fiqh & LawJurist: Shaykh Bashir al-NajafiTopic: Clinical DeathMadhhab / school: Shia Ithna 'AshariyahSection: Medical Issues#fiqh#najafi#qa
Suggest a correction or extra detail
Open to everyone — no account needed. A moderator reviews every suggestion.
My mother is in the hospital and she is breathing through the respiratory system, which I cannot bear the costs, and her brain stops working and doctors advised me to turn off the device because she is dead by a high percentage. If the device is turned off, she will die completely. Is it permissible to turn off the device because it is too expensive?
Answer
In the name of Allah, In the name of Allah, if it is known that the movement of the heart and blood flow in the arteries is by the strength of the machine only, and there is no remaining force in the body of the person this blood movement, then he is legally dead. However, if the machine and medications help the instinctive movement which maintains blood flow in the arteries, he is alive but weak. It is known that the loss of consciousness leads to a loss of pain, so it makes no sense to say that stopping aid with medication and others is a relief for a person. Therefore, it is not permissible to remove the devices from him and expedite his death. Allah knows best.