Some people question the Shia belief in the infallibility of their Imams and the existence of their Mahdi,…
Some people question the Shia belief in the infallibility of their Imams and the existence of their Mahdi, with some scholars reportedly in contact with him, around thirty people. They wonder, if this is true, how such a degree of disagreement is possible among the Shia, where nearly every scholar or Marja seems to have his own interpretation. Furthermore, they note the claim of Imam Al-Mahdi’s inaccessibility, yet Shia scholars report numerous sightings. How can these contradictions coexist?
Answer
In the name of Allah, the denial of “sight” here refers specifically to the end of the four exclusive deputies’ role (may Allah be pleased with them) as representatives of Imam Mahdi. Personal visions without claims of formal representation may be granted by Allah’s will. As for scholars' differences in rulings, they arise from scholarly processes taught by the Imams (PBUT), the Prophet (PBUH), and Allah Himself. The general Shia are instructed to follow the most knowledgeable living scholar during the Imam’s occultation. Allah is the Guide.
Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com
Comments (0)
No comments yet.