My question is about the work of Shazdah Qassem Mandi in Pakistan, many scholars reject it. Is it permissible…

Answer

In the name of Allah, be advised that the narrations that come from the different ways related to the details of the tragic event of Taff are different and contradictory and some of them are vague. Most of the partial events of this tragedy cannot be confirmed. Rather, we assert that the master of the martyrs came out with his family from the city to Mecca and then to Karbala and martyred with a group of his family and his companions, and then the family was captured, whereas the rest of them who stayed alive returned to the Madina. As for the issue of marriage Qasim Ibin Hassan (PBUH) was not proved in an authentic reference. Those who read regarding such topics must pay attention to that. Allah is the all-Guide and Helper.