There are pilgrimage texts (zyarats) mentioned by Al-Mashhadi in his book Al-Mazar that he does not attribute…
There are pilgrimage texts (zyarats) mentioned by Al-Mashhadi in his book Al-Mazar that he does not attribute to an infallible and they do not appear in any other sources. Based on this, there are two issues: 1.Is every pilgrimage text transmitted by him about the infallibles (PBUT) considered authentic, even if it is not properly attributed to them? 2.Should the texts transmitted by him, which are attributed to an infallible, be treated like the other books of visits?
Answer
1: In the name of Allah, attributing a pilgrimage text or supplication to an infallible (PBUH) without an authentic chain of transmission is not permissible. This does not mean, however, that one cannot benefit from the supplication or visit itself. Allah is the Guide, and He is the All-knowing. 2: In the name of Allah, the status of such texts is similar to that of unauthenticated narrations in terms of legal rulings. Allah is the All-knowing.
Source:alnajafy.com · alnajafy.com
Comments (0)
No comments yet.